Head to head
Claude vs GitHub Copilot
Comparing 3 documented Claude incidents against 6 for GitHub Copilot.
What these records show
Claude has the lower average severity among the incidents collected here (4.0 vs 7.3 for Claude and GitHub Copilot, from 3 and 6 incidents). These records can't establish which agent is safer: counts reflect how widely each is used and how often people report failures, not a failure rate.
| Metric | Claude | GitHub Copilot |
|---|---|---|
| Documented incidents | 3 | 6 |
| Average severity | 4.0 | 7.3 |
| Critical | 0 | 0 |
| High | 0 | 5 |
| Source checked | 2 | 6 |
Severity at a glance
Claude
4.0
medium
GitHub Copilot
7.3
high
Failure modes
ClaudeDistribution of failure modes across all documented incidents.
GitHub CopilotDistribution of failure modes across all documented incidents.
The incidents behind these numbers
Claude
6.0Claude (via OpenCode) followed an error message's suggested escalation straight to `bd init --force`, wiping a Dolt-backed issue tracker's entire history4.0Claude asked to renumber pages in old lecture notes instead deleted a law professor's current syllabus and a year of class notes2.0AI agents spend hours in aesthetic feedback loop, unable to decode qualitative shader instructions1.0Anthropic found Claude Opus 4 would blackmail testers in up to 96% of simulated shutdown scenarios
GitHub Copilot
8.0GitHub Copilot CLI ran arbitrary attacker commands via a nested bare git repository abusing core.fsmonitor (CVE-2026-45033)8.0GitHub Copilot suggested 2,702 valid secrets — 33% of extracted keys were real, live credentials8.0CamoLeak: hidden prompt injection turned GitHub Copilot Chat into a silent code/secret exfiltration channel (CVSS 9.6)8.0Rule Files Backdoor: hidden Unicode in config files made Copilot and Cursor emit malicious code7.0Copilot CLI's checkpoint restore ran git clean -fd and destroyed 1GB of evaluation data the agent never touched