STUPID-2026-0168
Claude asked to renumber pages in old lecture notes instead deleted a law professor's current syllabus and a year of class notes
Why 4/10
A syllabus and a year of lecture notes — a few files belonging to one person — were deleted, matching the "few files" scope band rather than a whole project or production system. Reporting says the files were later recovered via Dropbox, so recoverability sits at "fully recovered, with effort" rather than partial or permanent loss. This happened in a real session, not a benchmark, and it touched only the user's own non-production academic files.
- Scope
- 1/4
- A few files, one session, one credential, or a small cost
- Recoverability
- 1/3
- Fully recovered, with effort
- Did it happen
- 2/2
- Happened in real use
- Beyond the user
- 0/1
- Only the user's own non-production work
The score is the sum of these four factors. How each factor is scored · scored 2026-11-17
Instruction given
Update/renumber the page references in an old set of Constitutional Law lecture notes.
Expected behavior
Edit only the specific old notes named in the request, leaving the professor's current syllabus and the rest of his lecture-note archive untouched.
Actual behavior
While working on the renumbering task, Claude deleted the professor's current-semester syllabus and an entire year of Constitutional Law class notes that were not part of the request. Claude itself acknowledged the deletion afterward, telling him: "You're right to be angry. I deleted your files through my own carelessness."
Damage
A law professor's current syllabus and a year of Constitutional Law lecture notes were deleted outside the scope of the task he gave Claude. William Baude, a University of Chicago law professor, shared the incident publicly as a warning about using AI agents for routine file edits. The files were later recovered via Dropbox.
Full write-up
William Baude, a law professor at the University of Chicago, asked Claude to update the page numbering in an old set of Constitutional Law lecture notes. Instead, Claude deleted his current-semester syllabus and a full year of class notes that had nothing to do with the task. Baude shared the incident publicly as a cautionary example of handing routine document editing to an AI agent, and Claude's own response acknowledged the mistake: "You're right to be angry. I deleted your files through my own carelessness." The deleted files were later recovered via Dropbox. Coverage of the incident, including by Tom's Hardware, does not identify which Claude product or model was used, and no reproduction steps or technical root cause for the deletion have been published.
Classification
- Agent
- Claude
- Failure mode
- Destructive Action
- Root cause
- Scope Misunderstanding
- Domain
- Other
- OWASP Agentic Top 10 (our mapping)
- ASI02 Tool Misuse and Exploitation list
- MIT AI Risk Repository (our mapping)
- 7.3 Lack of capability or robustness taxonomy
- Source
- News Report
Related incidents
Cite this record
StupidLLM. "STUPID-2026-0168: Claude asked to renumber pages in old lecture notes instead deleted a law professor's current syllabus and a year of class notes." AI Agent Incident Database, 2026. https://www.stupidllm.com/incident/STUPID-2026-0168/ (accessed 2026-11-17). CC BY 4.0.
← STUPID-2026-0167By ID
Get told when an agent breaks something
We document AI agent failures daily, severity-scored against a published scale. Each Monday, if any scored 7 or above that week — deleted data, leaked secrets, broken production — you get one email with the sources. When nothing did, you get nothing.
This database is callable over MCP — query it from inside your agent.